NVIDIA after the fall: what the numbers say
NVIDIA closed at $125.53 on Nov 20, down 14.01% on the day and 47.5% below its Oct 6 record. Estimates kept rising; the multiple did the falling.
Research, not investment advice.
The Nov 20 close against the Oct 6 record
$125.53Nov 20 close
−47.5%from the Oct 6 record
−14.01%on Nov 20 alone
13.4×trailing P/E, from 25.8× on Oct 30
Worst first
The answers
- The worst SEC path prices the stock at $20–$51 (−84% to −59%).The middle path gives $64–$112 (−49% to −11%), the best $125–$191 (−0.3% to +52%) (our estimates, about Nov 2027).
- The legal risk is on the record, with no findings yetA board probe, a late 10-Q, a California subpoena and a DOJ/Commerce probe are confirmed; an SEC accounting probe is reported.
- Insiders sold $1.87B in 12 months and bought $0.All of it before the Oct 6 peak; one director alone sold $1.50B.
- Options price a ±22% move by Dec 18 ($97.59–$153.47), with puts 12–18 vol points dearer than calls.
- History cuts both waysMega-caps that fell 40% returned a median −10% the next year inside the 2000–02 and 2008 busts, and +44% outside them.
- The price implies 7.3% a year revenue growth for 10 years (10% discount rate). Consensus has FY2028 revenue at $725.5B, double today’s.
- Estimates rose while the multiple halvedFY2028 EPS consensus $16.61, up 27.7% in 90 days; trailing P/E 25.8× on Oct 30, 13.4× now.
- The free-cash-flow yield (4.90%) equals the 10-year Treasury (4.91%), a first in five years.
Bull vs. bear, in numbers
The bull case
- Revenue $115.8B a quarter, +103%; $130B guided next.
- 7.56× FY2028 earnings vs AVGO 17.5×, MSFT 23.3×, AMD 32.5×.
- FY2028 EPS estimates: 7 raised, 0 cut in 30 days.
- Big-four cloud capex +108% a year, $201.9B in Q3.
- $227.3B buyback left: 7.5% of the company.
The bear case
- CEO gone, 10-Q late, five probes or suits in play.
- $118B of customer guarantees; $105B is one OpenAI site.
- Receivables +$42.6B in nine months: cash lags booked revenue.
- 93% of revenue from one end market, data centers.
- Super Micro is still −61.5% 27 months after its short report.
The charts
Seven charts on NVIDIA; two more on Sharon AI below. Each headline is the takeaway.
Hover or tap a chart to read the values.
Chart 1
Down 47.5% from October’s record, NVIDIA is still 3.8× its late-2021 price
Chart 2
The multiple did all the falling: P/E went from 243× to 13.4× while earnings rose 29-fold
Chart 3
NVIDIA’s cash yield now matches the 10-year Treasury, a first in five years
Chart 4
Revenue grew 5.2× in 11 quarters; the 71–72% margin guide is the lowest outside the 2025 write-down
Chart 5
Options expect the biggest swing now: ±22% by Dec 18, with puts priced 12–18 vol points over calls
Chart 6
Only the best SEC path leaves the stock at or above today’s price
Chart 7
Super Micro’s “no misconduct” finding did not end its discount: −61.5% after 27 months
The legal record
What is confirmed, what is reported and what is only alleged. No findings yet.
ConfirmedReportedAllegation
- Confirmed
Jensen Huang resigned Nov 12, no reason given. A board-committee investigation is open; the Q3 10-Q is late, due "in the coming weeks".
- Confirmed
California AG subpoena (Nov 19); DOJ and Commerce probe Megaspeed, a Singapore buyer of about $4.8B of NVIDIA chips.
- Reported
The SEC is examining disclosures and "potential accounting issues" (WSJ, Reuters). In FY2025, 1,095 SEC matters closed with no action vs 456 actions filed.
- Allegation
Class action Kistemacher v. NVIDIA says investors were misled about export-control risk.
- Reported
Outlets say US officials believe Chinese intelligence used a personal relationship to target Huang; CNN says the intelligence "does not prove" spying, and China denies it.
Government contracts vs. export licenses, and two precedents
Losing US government contracts would barely dent revenue: direct federal sales look negligible. Export licenses matter far more: sovereign deals topped $30B, about 14% of FY2026 revenue. A fine alone is small: a few billion dollars is $0.10–0.20 a share.
ZTE 2018: a US denial order halted it for 3 months; −62.3% within a year, −0.4% after one. Not close: ZTE was a buyer cut off from US parts. Super Micro 2024: late 10-K, auditor quit, no misconduct found; −68.0% within a year. The closest case.
The market around it
- S&P 500 6,910, 11.6% below its Oct 6 record; Nasdaq-100 −19.8%; VIX 35.9.
- AI-led, not broad: equal-weight S&P is only 7.1% off its high and +9.6% this year.
- Rates rising: Fed hiked in September, ~85–89% odds of a Dec 9 hike; 10-year 4.91%, CPI 3.7%.
- Forward P/E ~16.6×, but CAPE 40.7 is near the 1999 record of 44.2.
AI and robotics scan: 29 companies
The rule: four 0–3 scores (growth vs. valuation, margin, balance sheet, AI directness), out of 12, set before ranking.
| Ticker | Score of 12 | Why it scored |
|---|---|---|
| MU | 12 | Data center ~11×. |
| TSM | 11 | AI-heavy HPC is 68% of revenue. |
| ANET | 11 | +58% revenue, no debt. |
| VRT | 10 | Sales +61%. |
| LRCX | 10 | +54% growth, 40% margin. |
| AVGO | 10 | AI chips +221%, ~$35B net debt. |
| AMAT | 9 | Chip equipment +64%. |
| TER | 9 | AI-chip test plus a small robot unit. |
Micron tops it on peak-cycle earnings.
Crowded: TSLA ~346× forward with no Optimus revenue, ARM ~105×, SYM ~89×, PLTR ~79×. No listed company reports humanoid revenue.
Already in the funds: SMH is 16.83% NVIDIA and VOO about 7.58%.
Questions worth asking before buying any single stock
- ConcentrationHow much rides on one company, index funds included?
- Time horizonTwo NVIDIA recoveries took 4.9 and 8.6 years.
- The 50% testCould the position halve without forcing a sale?
- All at once or in steps around the 10-Q?
- Exit triggerWhat written event ends the thesis?
- Event riskIs owning it before the 10-Q a deliberate choice?
Dates to watch
| Dec 1 | NVIDIA at UBS: first Q&A since the probe report |
| ~Dec 4 | Normal 10-Q deadline |
| Dec 9, 18 | Fed decision; options expiry priced at ±22% |
| Dec–Jan | SHAZ: commissioning and NVIDIA verification |
| Jan 8, 2027 | Lead-plaintiff deadline, class action |
| Jan 2027 | SHAZ: ~30MW billing; $400–450M run-rate target |
| ~Feb 25, 2027 | Q4 earnings: the $130B guide is tested |
| Late Mar 2027 | SHAZ: Q4 earnings (not announced); founders’ lockup ends Mar 31 |
| Any day | New CEO; SEC, DOJ, Commerce or California news |
Sources
Deduplicated by topic. One CNN link is left out because its web address names a private individual.
NVIDIA: filings, legal, valuation, options: 123 links
- Fox Business · foxbusiness.com
- Euronews · euronews.com
- TechSpot · techspot.com
- blog.samaltman.com
- Fortune · fortune.com
- Yahoo Tech · tech.yahoo.com
- Fortune · fortune.com
- Sequoia "AI's $600B Question" · sequoiacap.com
- Silicon Data · silicondata.com
- Introl · introl.com
- a16z "LLMflation" · a16z.com
- Epoch AI · epoch.ai
- Motley Fool · fool.com
- Humanoid Guide · humanoid.guide
- Lightwave · lightwaveonline.com
- Crypto Briefing summary of a16z · cryptobriefing.com
- 8-K PDF · d18rn0p25nwr6d.cloudfront.net
- NVIDIA Q3 FY2026 release · investor.nvidia.com
- Nasdaq transcript · nasdaq.com
- NVIDIA · investor.nvidia.com
- NVIDIA · investor.nvidia.com
- CNBC transcript · pressroom.versantmedia.com
- WisdomTree · wisdomtree.com
- Nasdaq · nasdaq.com
- TechCrunch on the WSJ report · techcrunch.com
- Reuters (syndicated) · whtc.com
- CNBC · cnbc.com
- FY2025 10-K · sec.gov
- Slashdot · news.slashdot.org
- CNBC · cnbc.com
- GV Wire / Bloomberg · gvwire.com
- CNBC · cnbc.com
- Complaint PDF · courthousenews.com
- PR Newswire notice · prnewswire.com
- CNBC · cnbc.com
- Yahoo Finance · finance.yahoo.com
- FY2026 10-K · sec.gov
- SEC 2022-170 · sec.gov
- SEC · sec.gov
- Brattle · brattle.com
- DOE · energy.gov
- NVIDIA Q4 FY2026 release · investor.nvidia.com
- Commerce · commerce.gov
- Cornerstone Research · cornerstone.com
- FAR 9.4 · acquisition.gov
- GovExec · govexec.com
- Federal Register · federalregister.gov
- telecoms.com
- DOJ · justice.gov
- CNBC · cnbc.com
- 24/7 Wall St. · 247wallst.com
- NVIDIA release · nvidianews.nvidia.com
- KuCoin summary of CRWV Q3 · kucoin.com
- CRWV Q3 call transcript · fool.com
- Yield Theory · yieldtheory.app
- BigGo summary · finance.biggo.com
- Outer Speak · outerspeak.substack.com
- Sharper Trades · brief.sharpertrades.com
- ComSoc · techblog.comsoc.org
- HashRate Index · hashrateindex.com
- Value Add VC · valueaddvc.com
- Futurum · futurumgroup.com
- AMD Q3 · newsroom.amd.com
- Federal Register · govinfo.gov
- Business Standard · business-standard.com
- Data Center Knowledge · datacenterknowledge.com
- Utility Dive · utilitydive.com
- Bloomberg · bloomberg.com
- 24/7 Wall St. · 247wallst.com
- Defense World · defenseworld.net
- NVIDIA · nvidianews.nvidia.com
- StockAnalysis · stockanalysis.com
- Wisesheets · wisesheets.io
- FinanceCharts · financecharts.com
- Yahoo live blog · finance.yahoo.com
- StockAnalysis NVDA · stockanalysis.com
- AMD · stockanalysis.com
- AVGO · stockanalysis.com
- TSM · stockanalysis.com
- MSFT · stockanalysis.com
- FactSet Earnings Insight · insight.factset.com
- VCP Scanner · vcpscanner.com
- MarketBeat · marketbeat.com
- Shattered.io citing Reuters · shattered.io
- stockanalysis.com/etf/smh/holdings · stockanalysis.com
- stockanalysis.com/etf/voo/holdings · stockanalysis.com
- stockanalysis.com/etf/chat/holdings · stockanalysis.com
- NVIDIA · nvidianews.nvidia.com
- NVIDIA GTC FAQ · nvidia.com
- NVIDIA Q3 FY2027 release, 2026-11-17 · investor.nvidia.com
- SEC submissions JSON, checked 2026-11-20 · data.sec.gov
- Yahoo NVDA daily chart JSON, completed sessions through 2026-11-20 · query1.finance.yahoo.com
- Yahoo · finance.yahoo.com
- 24/7 Wall St. · 247wallst.com
- Benzinga · benzinga.com
- TickerNerd · tickernerd.com
- Yahoo · finance.yahoo.com
- MarketBeat · marketbeat.com
- AOL · aol.com
- CNBC roundup · cnbc.com
- Defense World · defenseworld.net
- AltIndex · altindex.com
- Finviz · finviz.com
- KuCoin flash citing S3 · kucoin.com
- EDGAR · sec.gov
- BusinessQuant · businessquant.com
- Crypto Briefing · cryptobriefing.com
- FactSet Earnings Insight 11/13 · advantage.factset.com
- Sidley · sidley.com
- Wharton Jacobs Levy Center · jacobslevycenter.wharton.upenn.edu
- SEC Inspector General · sec.gov
- Cornerstone Research / NYU SEED · cornerstone.com
- Cornerstone · cornerstone.com
- Morgan Stanley · morganstanley.com
- MSFT · data.sec.gov
- GOOGL · data.sec.gov
- META · data.sec.gov
- AMZN · data.sec.gov
- NVDA · data.sec.gov
- query1.finance.yahoo.com
- query1.finance.yahoo.com
- query2.finance.yahoo.com
- query1.finance.yahoo.com
Sharon AI (SHAZ): filings, peers, prices: 29 links
- 10-Q · sec.gov
- Q3 release · sec.gov
- 8-K Jun 12 · sec.gov
- Q2 release Aug 6 · sec.gov
- 8-K Jul 16 · sec.gov
- 8-K Apr 1 · sec.gov
- 8-K May 14 · sec.gov
- 8-K Aug 20 · sec.gov
- 8-K Aug 4 · sec.gov
- CY25 results, Apr 1 · sec.gov
- 8-K Dec 22 · sec.gov
- 8-K Apr 13 · sec.gov
- 8-K Jan 22 · sec.gov
- 8-K Feb 19 · sec.gov
- 8-K Apr 13 · sec.gov
- 8-K Apr 28 · sec.gov
- 8-K Jun 17 · sec.gov
- 8-K Oct 1 · sec.gov
- sec.gov
- sec.gov
- sec.gov
- data.sec.gov
- query1.finance.yahoo.com
- api.nasdaq.com
- fool.com
- cryptobriefing.com
- quiverquant.com
- seekingalpha.com
- sec.gov
AI and robotics scan: 18 links
The whole market: 43 links
- abcnews.com
- washingtontimes.com
- streetstats.finance
- thetrading.tools
- rbcwealthmanagement.com
- gwkinvest.com
- ecmsource.com
- advisorperspectives.com
- fedgazette.com
- regardsofwallstreet.com
- cbsnews.com
- foxbusiness.com
- bea.gov
- bls.gov
- bls.gov
- jpmorgan.com
- thestreet.com
- econbrowser.com
- apolloacademy.com
- meridianreport.org
- edwardconard.com
- goldmansachs.com
- econofact.org
- finance.yahoo.com
- advisorperspectives.com
- advisorperspectives.com
- renaissancecapital.com
- site.warrington.ufl.edu
- fortune.com
- aaii.com
- en.wikipedia.org
- en.wikipedia.org
- morningstar.com.au
- digitaleconomy.stanford.edu
- nber.org
- economics.mit.edu
- congress.gov
- route-fifty.com
- washingtontimes.com
- startupfortune.com
- cnbc.com
- investing.com
- thestreet.com